Good-quality raw milk is required to make good-quality dairy products. Once raw milk is defective, it cannot be improved during processing, and defects often become more pronounced. Therefore, it is important that raw milk be produced and handled from farm to plant under conditions that do not reduce its quality or, consequently, the quality of the product. Many factors can influence the quality of raw milk. Following is a summary of raw milk quality parameters, testing procedures and limits. and how they may influence the quality of dairy products:
Please check this link first if you are interested in organic or specialty dairy production.
Herd Health and Somatic Cells
As a rule, unhealthy dairy cows have the potential to give milk that is lower in quality and wholesomeness. Mastitis, an infection of the udder, is one of the most common herd health concerns. Mastitis in dairy cows, which is most often the result of a bacterial infection (contagious or environmental), causes an increase in milk somatic cell levels (blood cells that fight infections). While the legal limit for bulk milk is 750,000 cells per milliliter (ml), somatic cell counts (SCC) exceeding 300,000 generally indicate some level of mastitis in the herd. High SCCs have been associated with the potential for quality defects in raw milk and in processed dairy products. Quality defects are generally the result of enzymes associated with the infection and the somatic cells. These enzymes break down proteins, fats, and other components, resulting in reduced cheese yields and flavor defects (e.g., bitterness, rancidity) in cheese and possibly pasteurized milk and other products.
Milk as it is secreted from the udder of a healthy cow is very low in bacterial numbers. Bacteria can increase in raw milk due to poor milking methods, inadequate cleaning of milk equipment, poor cooling, and, in some cases, as a result of mastitis. Good production and herd management practices help ensure low bacteria counts and reduce the risk of the presence of pathogens in the raw milk. While the legal limit for total bacteria in farm raw milk is 100,000/ml, milk with counts of 10,000 or less is considered desirable and achievable by most farms. Like somatic cells, bacteria produce enzymes that degrade proteins, fats, and other components, resulting in reduced product quality when counts are high. Although pasteurization and more severe heat treatments (Ultra-High Temperature) kill a majority of bacteria in milk, some strains produce enzymes that survive the heat treatment. Heat-stable enzymes have the potential of further degrading the processed product, especially long-life, shelf-stable products (UHT milk). Certain types of bacteria may survive pasteurization and among these, certain strains can grow under refrigeration, limiting the shelf life of milk products. Following is a list of methods commonly used to evaluate raw milk bacteriological quality, including the required Standard Plate Count, as well as auxiliary tests sometimes used to evaluate raw milk (for more information see “Sources of Bacteria in Raw Milk”):
Standard Plate Count (SPC) determines the total number of bacteria that can grow and form countable colonies on Standard Methods Agar when incubated aerobically at 32°C (90°F) for 48 hours. Generally, SPC values should be less than 10,000/ml. The legal maximum for producer milk is 100,000/ml. Extremely high counts in raw milk (e.g., due to poor cooling) can cause defects in raw milk that result in its rejection, due to off-odors and flavors such as sour, malty, or rancid. These and other microbial defects can carry over into products.
Preliminary Incubation Count (PIC) is performed by holding milk samples at 12.8°C (55°F) for 18 hours prior to performing the SPC. This incubation temperature selects for bacterial contaminants in a sample that can grow at cooler temperatures, some of which may have the potential for further growth during raw milk storage. The PIC should always be compared to the unincubated SPC. There is no legal limit for the PIC, but the goal is for no significant increase over the fresh SPC. PIC limits of three to four times the SPC, or less than a specific count, such as 50,000 or 100,000/ml, have been used. The test is most often used as a tool to detect possible deficiencies in farm cleaning, sanitizing, and milk handling procedures that may not influence and/or be detected by the SPC procedure.
Laboratory Pasteurization Count (LPC) is performed by heating the milk sample to 62.8°C (145°F) for 30 minutes (simulates batch pasteurization) followed by an SPC. This procedure counts bacteria that survive pasteurization (thermoduric bacteria). LPCs of less than 250/ml should be the goal. The legal maximum SPC for pasteurized milk is 20,000/ml. This test is also used as an indicator of possible deficiencies in farm procedures.
Coliform Bacteria Count is performed by plating a sample on the media Violet Red Bile Agar, which selects for coliform bacteria. Coliforms are associated with fecal and environmental contamination. Counts of less than 50/ml should be the goal; < 25 is achievable. There are no legal limits for raw milk unless coliforms cause the SPC to exceed 100,000/ml. Coliforms are associated with filth contamination and a higher potential for pathogens.
Antibiotics and Drug Residues
Antibiotics and other drugs are often used to treat cows with mastitis or other infections or ailments. When a cow is treated, its milk is generally withheld from the bulk tank until treatment stops and milk is free of drug residues. The most commonly used drugs are the beta-lactam antibiotics (i.e., the penicillin family). Occasionally, treated cows are overlooked, and antibiotic-contaminated milk enters the bulk tank. However, all raw milk tank trucks are screened for the presence of beta-lactam drugs at dairy plants before they are unloaded, therefore minimizing the potential for drug contaminants in processed dairy products. Individual farm samples are also tested routinely or for producer trace-back if a truck tests positive. Antibiotics in milk are a concern due to the risk of allergic reactions and the development of antibiotic-resistant pathogens. During the manufacture of cheese and cultured dairy products, antibiotics can inhibit dairy starter cultures used to develop acid (e.g., lactic acid bacteria), which can result in the loss of significant amounts of product and milk.
Water and Freezing Point of Milk
Added water can occur in milk due to both unintentional (e.g., poor system drainage) and intentional addition. Added water can be detected in milk by measuring its freezing point. The freezing point is slightly less than that of pure water and relatively constant. Typical milk generally has a freezing point below minus 0.542 degrees Hortvett (°H is a scale used almost exclusively for milk freezing point), a derivative of degrees Celsius). When water is added to milk, the freezing point increases approximately 0.005°H for every 1% water added. The state of New York uses a cut-off of -0.530°H or higher (less negative) as cause for investigation. Added water reduces the value of the milk by diluting the protein and other milk components that will influence product yields. Added water in fluid milk can also dilute the sweetness, potentially resulting in a “flat” taste.
Sediment in milk is generally due to poor pre-milking hygiene procedures that allow soil and other materials to enter the milking stream. Proper environmental conditions for cow cleanliness are important to reduce soil on animals so that pre-milking hygiene procedures can be effective. Sediment in milk is measured by filtering the milk through a fine filter and visually examining it. High sediment levels in milk are associated with filth and the potential for bacterial contaminants that will influence quality.
Off-flavors and odors can be present in raw milk due to practices on the farm. Some are minor and difficult to avoid, while others are due to poor practices and can be reason for rejecting a milk load. Most flavor/odor defects will be carried over into the finished product, although some of the volatile defects can be partially removed. Defects in milk can be classified as:
Absorbed – cows breathing in odors in the air can transmit these to the milk through the bloodstream, while some odors can be directly absorbed by the milk during storage;
Bacterial – growth of spoilage microorganisms; or
Chemical – related enzymes, feed, and health of the cow as well as milk handling procedures (e.g., cleaning chemicals).
For more information, see the handout “Flavor and Odor Defects in Milk.” The most common raw milk related off-flavors/odors and their causes are:
Barny/Cowy: Associated with strong barn odors (e.g., poor barn aeration) absorbed by the cow or the milk during storage. Some animals will produce “cowy” milk that is related to poor animal health (e.g., ketosis).
Feedy: Associated with strong feed odors that are absorbed by the cow or directly into the milk during storage. Feed flavors/odors most often mimic the nature of the feed (e.g., silage, hay, soy). They are often present in low levels not considered objectionable, although strong feed flavors/odors, especially those related to poor-quality feeds, may be cause to reject milk. Feed flavors can be minimized by not feeding immediately before milking. Related off-flavors include those of wild onion/garlic (especially in the South).
Malty/Acid/Sour: Due to the growth of bacteria that produce acid, some of which can produce a “malty” defect. Most often associated with poor cooling of the milk (e.g., from a farm with a broken compressor).
Oxidized: Cardboardy or “old-oil” odor and flavor resulting from the oxidation of milk fats in the presence of metals (such as copper contamination). Feeds high in certain fats (e.g., soybeans) and/or low levels of vitamin E in the cows’ diet may also increase the milk’s susceptibility to oxidation.
Rancid: Sour-like defect that occurs in milk due to excessive agitation and other factors related to increasing the susceptibility of the milk fat to the hydrolytic enzyme lipase. Lipase breaks down butterfat to free fatty acids (such as butyric) that can result in rancid off-flavors (e.g., soapy, baby-vomit, blue cheese).
Dairy Foods Science Notes
Department of Food Science
Stocking Hall, Ithaca, NY 14853